Mesha Rashi: The Primordial Ram, Cardinal Fire, and the Genesis of Sovereign Will
Mesha (Aries) is the primordial spark of the zodiacal wheel, anchoring the celestial coordinate from 0°00' to 30°00'. Where the closing currents of Meena (Pisces) dissolve form back into the boundless cosmic ocean, Mesha erupts as the sudden, concentrated impulse of existence: Ahamkara, the birth of the individual "I." It is pure kinetic energy crossing the threshold from the unmanifest into manifest time and space. This is the rashi of the unhesitating pioneer, the warrior-creator, and the raw biological drive to survive, conquer, and command reality through decisive action.
Astronomically, Mesha is delineated across the constellation of Aries, anchored by the luminous navigational star Hamal (Alpha Arietis) alongside Sheratan and Mesarthim. Hamal, derived from the Arabic phrase for the head of the ram, shines with an unyielding orange-red hue, serving as a beacon of independence, sharp intellect, and martial leadership. In classical Vedic iconography, Mesha is embodied by a virile, golden-horned Ram, head lowered, muscles coiled, prepared to breach barriers that seem insurmountable to ordinary vision.
The planetary ruler of Mesha is Mangala (Mars), the celestial commander (Senapati), engineer of kinetic drive, muscular strength, executive courage, and internal metabolic fire (Tejas). Encompassing the entire four padas of Ashwini (ruled by Ketu), the four padas of Bharani (ruled by Shukra), and the opening pada of Krittika (ruled by Surya), Mesha synthesizes sudden, lightning-fast initiation with deep, transformative gestation and sharp, purifying solar focus. Classified as a Chara (movable, cardinal), Agni (fiery), and Purusha (masculine, active) sign, Mesha represents the ultimate cosmic crucible of pioneering leadership, cranial vitality, and physical sovereignty.
Technical Profile and Cosmic Signifiers
Astronomical Identity: Constellation of Aries, anchored by Hamal (Alpha Arietis)
Zodiacal Span: 0°00' to 30°00' Sidereal Zodiac (Mesha)
Ruling Planet: Mars (Mangala / Kuja), governing raw vitality, courage, red blood cells, skeletal muscle, and directional drive
Associated Nakshatras:
· Ashwini (Pada 1–4)
· Bharani (Pada 1–4)
· Krittika (Pada 1)
Elemental Mode: Agni (Cardinal / Movable Fire)
Modality and Gender: Chara (Movable/Dynamic), Purusha (Masculine / Expressive / Projective)
Anatomical Governance: Cranium, brain, cerebral hemispheres, skull bones, forehead, motor cortex, and facial nerve pathways
Guna Progression: Rajasic core driven toward direct worldly assertion and physical conquest
Dosha and Ayurveda: Pitta, governing metabolic combustion, enzymatic transformations, and bile production
Sacred Tree and Botanical Resonance: Kuchila / Nux Vomica (Strychnos nux-vomica) and Khair / Cutch Tree (Senegalia catechu)
Psychological Archetypes and Behavioral Energetics
Mesha represents the pure unmediated eruption of Mars through a cardinal fire sign. It does not pause to negotiate, calibrate, or reflect; it acts. The archetype of Mesha is the trailblazer, the surgeon, the battlefield commander, the athlete, and the solitary explorer who hacks a path through dense jungle so that the rest of the zodiac can follow.
This is not the calculated ambition of Makara (Capricorn) or the regal, institutional authority of Simha (Leo). Mesha's fire is primal, immediate, and direct. It possesses the innocence of a newborn accompanied by the sheer, unbridled force of an erupting volcano. Mesha natives possess an unmistakable directness. Their eyes are sharp, forward-focused, and unblinking; their physical gait is purposeful, often leaning slightly forward from the head, as if their consciousness is perpetually racing ahead of their physical form.
They are natural disruptors of stagnation: trauma surgeons, startup founders, trial lawyers, emergency responders, and mechanical innovators. They exude a brisk, invigorating charisma that shatters complacency and rallies paralyzed minds into sudden momentum. Their presence is a tonic against dread, hesitation, and self-doubt.
The Gift of Sovereign Initiation
The core gift of Mesha is the courage to begin. Most human endeavors fail not from poor execution, but from the paralysis of anticipation. Mesha bypasses anticipation altogether. Where other signs see a wall of complex obstacles, Mesha sees a concrete obstacle that will inevitably yield to sufficient velocity and focused intent.
This pioneering faculty operates across all life dimensions. At the mental level, it produces swift, decisive problem-solving and an innate ability to cut through bureaucratic clutter to find the core issue. At the social level, it manifests as radical honesty; a Mesha native rarely plays political games or cultivates hidden agendas. What you see is precisely what exists. At the physical level, it provides remarkable recuperative stamina, enabling rapid recovery from exhaustion or physical injury through sheer willpower.
Mesha natives possess an instinctive understanding of leverage. They know that a single, massive strike delivered at the critical point achieves what months of indecisive negotiation cannot. This decisive bravery, rooted in the cardinal fire of their sign, allows them to champion causes and confront realities that more diplomatic signs avoid.
The Instinctive Strategic Mind
While often stereotyped as merely reckless, a mature Mesha possesses an exceptionally acute strategic mind. It is the intelligence of tactical speed. Mesha processes inputs instantaneously, assesses the line of maximum impact, and executes before the opposition has completed its assessment.
This tactical brilliance extends beyond crisis management. Mesha excels in dynamic, high-stakes environments where conditions shift minute by minute. They possess a natural affinity for tools, metals, high-precision instruments, and complex machinery. They understand how energy converts into work, how tension translates into movement, and how to harness raw friction to achieve victory.
Their courage is neither artificial nor performative. It stems from an inherent refusal to be governed by fear or external coercion. Mesha demands autonomy above all else; it would rather endure hardship on its own terms than thrive in comfortable subjugation.
The Shadow of the Scorched Earth
The shadow of Mesha emerges when its cardinal fire lacks counter-balance, devolving into blind impulsivity, belligerence, and tyrannical self-absorption. Because their primary instinct is forward motion, an ungrounded Mesha native perceives any delay, nuance, or dissent as an existential threat to be obliterated.
Like a battering ram that shatters the very doorframe of the house it is trying to enter, they can leave a wake of emotional devastation, alienated allies, and exhausted subordinates. Their impatience causes them to abandon complex projects halfway through the moment initial resistance requires quiet persistence rather than brute force.
Under stress, their cardinal directness degrades into cutting cruelty, sudden rage, or chronic irritability. They may weaponize honesty, mistaking blunt insensitivity for authenticity, completely oblivious to the emotional collateral damage inflicted on more sensitive signs.
There is also the recurring trap of "premature warfare." Mesha can become so addicted to friction, adrenaline, and conflict that it invents adversaries where none exist. When there is no mountain to scale or opponent to challenge, the martial energy turns inward, manifesting as chronic tension, hypertension, migraines, and emotional exhaustion.
The Core Psychological Lesson
The spiritual evolution of Mesha is learning the transition from the crude Warrior to the enlightened Protector (Kshatriya), shifting from egoic domination to the disciplined defense of Dharma.
The first lesson is the mastery of patience and pause. Mesha must discover that restraint is not weakness, and strategic silence is often more lethal than premature speech. They must understand that true strength lies not in the capacity to hit, but in the sovereign self-control required to withhold the strike until the precise cosmic moment arrives.
The second lesson is relational empathy. Mesha must learn that other human beings are not obstacles, rivals, or instruments for its personal agenda, but sovereign souls with distinct rhythms and vulnerabilities. When Mesha learns to place its formidable shield in front of the vulnerable rather than using its sword to clear a path solely for itself, it achieves its highest evolutionary destiny.
The PreHealing Perspective: Neuro-Cranial Combustion, HPA-Axis Hyperarousal, and Musculoskeletal Drive
In somatic biology and functional medicine, Mesha governs the cranium, cerebral circulation, cranial nerve pathways, the motor cortex, skeletal muscular tone, and the bioenergetics of cellular oxidation (Agni).
This sign represents the biological ignition system. Where Meena governs the lymphatic wash and dissolution of metabolic footprints, Mesha represents the release of stored glycogen, the neurochemical surge of catecholamines, and the instantaneous conversion of metabolic potential into kinetic output. Understanding Mesha's somatic architecture provides deep insight into acute inflammatory pathways, stress physiology, and cranial equilibrium.
The Neurobiology of Cranial Drive and the Sympathetic Nervous System
Physiologically, Mesha rules the skull, the brain mass, the meninges, the frontal lobes, the eyes, the cerebral vascular network, and the sympathetic branch of the autonomic nervous system.
Governed by Mars, Mesha directly correlates with the body's acute stress response mediated by the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis. It dictates the rapid secretion of adrenaline, noradrenaline, and dopamine, directing blood away from viscera toward skeletal muscle and the motor strip of the cerebral cortex.
When Mesha is balanced, neurovascular tone is exceptionally sharp. Cerebral perfusion is optimal, cognitive processing speed is elevated, mental resilience is resilient, and the body possesses an innate capacity for deep physical labor and fast muscular recovery. The individual displays exceptional physical courage, razor-sharp motor coordination, and an unflagging zest for physical existence.
When Mesha is dysregulated, this neuro-metabolic fire overheats the physiology: intractable tension headaches, vascular migraines, trigeminal neuralgia, acute dental inflammation, premature arterial hardening within cerebral vessels, and burnout driven by chronic sympathetic hyperarousal. The biological ignition system fails to down-regulate, turning the brain into an overheated engine running without adequate coolant.
The Cranio-Cervical Junction and Ocular-Cranial Hypertension
Stationed at the apex of the skeletal framework, Mesha governs the delicate structural interplay between the occiput, the atlas (C1), the axis (C2), and cranial venous drainage.
The muscular attachments of the suboccipital triangle and the temporalis muscles are acutely sensitive to the martial tension of Mesha. When a Mesha native represses anger, frustration, or their natural drive for autonomy, the somatic tension concentrates directly into the jaw (bruxism), the temporomandibular joint (TMJ), and the suboccipital band at the base of the skull.
This chronic muscular constriction impedes the return of blood through the internal jugular veins, increasing intracranial pressure and predisposing the native to bloodshot eyes, ocular hypertension, and sharp, throbbing pain radiating behind the orbits. The body somaticizes unexpressed Martian rage as literal pressure within the cranium.
Metabolic Oxidation, Erythropoiesis, and Muscle Tone
Mesha governs the iron content of hemoglobin and the integrity of red blood cells (Rakta Dhatu). Mars directs the uptake of dietary iron, cellular respiration, and the oxygenation capacity of skeletal muscle tissue.
This connection between iron, oxygen delivery, and kinetic drive is foundational to Mesha’s somatic endurance. When this energy is balanced, cellular mitochondria burn fuel cleanly, lactic acid is cleared efficiently through the Cori cycle, and muscular tone remains firm and responsive without hypertonicity.
When dysregulated, this manifests as acute systemic inflammation, excessive hematocrit, spontaneous epistaxis (nosebleeds), acid peptic disease, skin eruptions characterized by red, angry pustules, and an accelerated production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) that ages cellular membranes prematurely.
The Neurobiology of Focused Drive
Mesha dictates the dopaminergic pathways of the prefrontal cortex that govern pursuit, novelty-seeking, and forward momentum. It is the neurochemical architecture that rewards effort, physical exertion, and the overcoming of resistance.
This circuitry is vital for life. It drives the organism to forage, protect territory, and overcome environmental adversity. It transforms abstract ideas into immediate, physical action.
When dysregulated, this dopamine circuitry loops into compulsive conflict, reckless risk-taking, and severe attention deficits when forced to engage in repetitive, sedentary tasks. The individual becomes an "adrenaline junkie," dependent on crises, confrontations, or extreme sports to feel neurologically alert, exhausting the adrenal cortex and depleting deep bodily fluids (Shukra/Ojas).
Pranayama as a Thermal Regulator
For Mesha natives, the breath is the primary mechanism for regulating neuro-cranial heat. Rapid, hyperventilative chest breathing common to stressed Mesha natives drives sympathetic dominance and spikes cerebral temperature.
Breath protocols that emphasize cooling, lengthened exhalations, specifically Sheetali, Sheetkari, and extended Chandra Bhedana (left nostril breathing) , act as an immediate somatic coolant. Cooling the air as it passes the palate cools the vascular beds of the nasopharynx, down-regulating the firing of the carotid sinus and soothing the motor cortex.
Nadi Shodhana practiced with a 1:2 inhale-to-exhale ratio without aggressive breath retention (Kumbhaka) helps ground erratic Martian fire, anchoring the restless cerebral prana back down into the solar plexus and pelvis.
Sound Therapy and Acoustic Resonance
Sound acts as an immediate frequency modulator for Mesha, specifically acoustics that can either channel raw martial drive into disciplined cadence or cool down an overheated, over-stimulated cranium.
Mantra Frequency
The primary mantra for Mesha is the Mangala Beeja Mantra (Om Kram Kreem Kroum Sah Bhaumaya Namah) , which honors Mars, the cosmic lord of the rashi. This mantra aligns the native's individual drive with the divine cosmic will, transforming blind aggression into focused, purposeful discipline and surgical intent.
Chanting the Narasimha Kavacham or the Angaraka Stotram cools the inflammatory potential of unguided Martian energy, neutralizing toxic heat within the blood and steadying the nervous system against panic and wrath.
The primal vibration of the seed syllable RAM (the Beeja mantra of the Manipura chakra) resonates deeply with Mesha's metabolic engine. Repeating RAM with awareness anchored in the naval center pulls excess, trapped heat downward from the cranium and restores metabolic balance.
For cooling down cranial inflammation, headaches, and racing thoughts, the gentle recitation of the Gayatri Mantra in a quiet whisper (Upanshu), followed by soothing chants dedicated to Chandra, restores parasympathetic tone and moistens parched cerebral tissues.
Classical Raga Interventions
Mesha responds to ragas that balance heroic valor (Veera Rasa) with serene, stabilizing, and cooling architecture.
Raga Bilawal offers a bright, structured, and tonic clarity that channels scattered martial energy into coherent, disciplined focus without overexciting the nervous system.
Raga Kafi, with its earthy, grounded, and slightly moist disposition, serves as a powerful balance to Mesha’s parched, cardinal fire. It calms erratic Pitta, grounds the impulsive motor drives, and soothes the emotional irritability that plagues an overworked mind.
To cool the system during acute stress or after intense physical labor, Raga Marwa, when approached during late afternoon, provides a deep, contemplative container that confronts internal restlessness, forcing the ego to surrender its aggressive demands.
During the heat of mid-day, when Mesha’s internal fire peaks, listening to Raga Sarang (specifically Shuddha Sarang) acts as an acoustic shade tree, calming ocular heat, reducing vascular pressure in the head, and inducing meditative tranquility.
For deep nocturnal restoration, the cool, profound waters of Raga Malkauns soothe the inflamed liver, cool the blood, and quiet the racing motor cortex, allowing the native to drop into deep, restorative slow-wave sleep.
Muhurta: Timing, Ritual, and Auspicious Activity
As a Chara (movable, dynamic) and Agni (fiery) sign, classical electional astrology (Muhurta) treats the transit of the Moon or the ascendant through Mesha as a high-velocity window suited for activities requiring decisive courage, physical speed, structural rupture, and direct initiation.
The lunar transit through Mesha occurs every 27.3 days, lasting approximately 2.25 days. Because of its swift, incisive nature, this window favors endeavors that require breaking through inertia, taking calculated operational risks, and establishing immediate momentum. It is a time for demolition, surgery, litigation, physical training, and bold beginnings that cannot afford the drag of doubt.
Favorable Pursuits
· Launching competitive ventures, startups, and aggressive marketing campaigns
· Undergoing surgical interventions, particularly those involving incisions or extractions
· Initiating high-intensity physical training programs, martial arts, and athletic regimes
· Purchasing, engineering, or testing metals, firearms, heavy machinery, and engines
· Demolishing old architectural structures to prepare land for new development
· Engaging in legal confrontations, administrative appeals, and decisive debates
· Starting exploration, solo travel, expeditions, and pioneering field research
· Conducting fire ceremonies (Homa / Havan) and rituals requiring intensive Tapas
· Cleansing protocols focused on burning metabolic toxins (Ama Pachana)
· Negotiating from a position of strength where clear, unyielding boundaries are required
What to Avoid
· Diplomatic negotiations that demand subtle compromise, tact, and conciliation
· Marriage ceremonies, romantic engagements, or reconciliation with estranged partners
· Long-term financial investments that require calm, stable, and passive maturation
· Delicate artistic, cosmetic, or aesthetic projects requiring soft nuances
· Signing complex, multi-layered contracts with extensive fine print while rushed
· Beginning extended restorative rest cures or grounding therapies
Mesha’s frequency is built to charge, cut, and claim. Subjecting it to indecisive dithering or demanding that it sit in passive, delicate conciliation frustrates its natural mechanics, breeding explosive resentment. During Mesha windows, act with precision, strike decisively, but ensure that your action is directed toward building a righteous boundary rather than scorching the earth around you.
Environmental Conditioning
Mesha thrives in environments that offer spatial freedom, thermal balance, and opportunities for physical challenge. The sign suffocates in cramped, overheated, highly bureaucratic, or aesthetically cluttered spaces.
Mesha is most balanced in:
· High-altitude, open spaces with crisp, cool mountain air that dissipates cranial heat
· Clean, minimalist living quarters free of unnecessary ornamental clutter
· Well-ventilated gyms, dojos, workshops, and physical training grounds
· Workspaces with direct, natural air circulation, cool architectural stone, and natural wood
· Environments near pristine, swiftly flowing rivers or waterfalls that balance the fire element
· Workstations featuring functional, state-of-the-art tools and machinery
· Spaces illuminated by clean, natural daylight rather than buzzing fluorescent lighting
· Rooms kept at a distinctly cool ambient temperature to preserve mental focus
· Clear, open horizons that allow the eyes to focus into the far distance, easing ocular strain
Mesha’s mind restores its equilibrium through physical exhaustion followed by cool stillness. They require spaces where they can exert their will without bureaucratic friction, balanced by environments that force their body to down-regulate its internal core temperature.
Nutritional and Botanical Support
Because Mesha’s innate constitution runs hot, dry, and intensely catabolic (Pitta-Vata aggravation), its nutritional strategy must pacify systemic heat, replenish depleted blood and liver glycogen, and lubricate the nervous system without dampening the metabolic digestive fire (Jatharagni).
The primary metabolic hazard for Mesha is the exhaustion of deep bodily fluids (Ojas) through excessive physical exertion, uncontrolled irritability, and reliance on stimulants like caffeine to sustain focus. Mesha natives require cooling, nutrient-dense, and deeply hydrating foods that soothe the mucosal lining of the stomach and protect the liver from oxidative burnout.
Nutritional Counter-Balance
Emphasize cooling, blood-purifying, and liver-supportive foods with bitter, sweet, and astringent tastes:
· Soaked and peeled almonds, providing essential fatty acids to soothe cerebral friction
· Sweet, juicy fruits like red pomegranates, sweet grapes, melons, and ripe figs
· Coconut water and pure coconut oil, which directly pacify internal Pitta and cool the liver
· Ghee (clarified butter) sourced from grass-fed cows, the sovereign medicine for brain tissue
· Grains such as barley, basmati rice, and oats, which provide sustained glycogen reserves
· Bitter leafy greens (dandelion, cilantro, kale, and fenugreek) to flush bile from the gallbladder
· Cooling herbal infusions of coriander seed, mint, fennel, and hibiscus
· Steamed zucchini, asparagus, cucumber, and yellow squash to maintain tissue hydration
· Lightly spiced mung bean soup (Moong Dal) cooked with cumin, coriander, and turmeric
Strictly limit excessive red meat, heavily salted processed snacks, sour fermented foods, pungent chilies, mustard oil, and alcohol. These substances pour fuel onto Mesha's internal furnace, immediately triggering acid reflux, angry skin eruptions, migraines, and emotional volatility. Avoid skipping meals; a hypoglycemic Mesha native quickly spirals into explosive irritability.
Herbal Support
Herbs that cool the blood, protect the liver, calm the motor cortex, and tonify the brain are essential for Mesha:
Brahmi / Gotu Kola (Centella asiatica) is the sovereign botanical ally for Mesha. It crosses the blood-brain barrier to cool neuro-inflammation, stabilize cerebral blood flow, reduce oxidative stress in the frontal cortex, and calm the racing mind without inducing lethargy.
Shankhpushpi (Convolvulus pluricaulis) is a premier nervine tonic that pacifies Pitta in the head. It relieves mental fatigue, reduces vascular tension in cranial blood vessels, and mitigates insomnia driven by an overactive motor cortex.
Manjistha (Rubia cordifolia) is the foremost blood purifier in Ayurvedic pharmacopeia. Its bitter, astringent properties cool the red blood cells (Rakta), clear heat from the liver, and soothe inflammatory skin conditions triggered by excess internal bile.
Neem (Azadirachta indica) provides profound bitter cooling action, draining systemic inflammation, balancing hyper-acidic digestive fires, and protecting the cardiovascular network from the ravages of prolonged stress.
Guduchi (Tinospora cordifolia) is a unique divine herb (Rasayana) that burns deep metabolic toxins (Ama) while simultaneously cooling the blood and rebuilding deep tissue vitality (Ojas). It prevents the systemic auto-immune flare-ups that occur when Mesha's fire attacks its own biological framework.
Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera) , when used selectively in cool milk or ghee, strengthens the adrenals and prevents muscular wasting, providing the grounded stamina needed to sustain Mesha’s explosive bursts of energy.
Botanical Medicine
The sacred botanical resonance for Mesha includes Kuchila (Strychnos nux-vomica) and Khair (Senegalia catechu / Acacia catechu).
While Kuchila contains intensely bitter alkaloids (strychnine and brucine) that in micro-doses historically acted as powerful neuro-muscular stimulants and metabolic tonics, it represents the raw, dangerous intensity of unrefined Martian power, a substance that can either kill or catalyze deep nervous vigor depending on dosage and preparation.
Khair (Cutch Tree) , on the other hand, provides the precise therapeutic counterbalance needed for Mesha's biological stability. Renowned for its exceptionally potent astringent, cooling, and anti-inflammatory bark, Khair is a master healer of bleeding disorders (Raktapitta), mouth ulcers, throat inflammation, and skin eruptions. Its high catechin content cools hyper-active vascular beds, tones spongy, inflamed tissues, and stabilizes gut permeability compromised by excess heat.
This botanical dynamic mirrors the spiritual path of Mesha. The raw, toxic heat of unrestrained impulse (Kuchila) must be tempered, cooled, and channeled through the astringent, grounding discipline of wisdom (Khair). Within the fiery drive to conquer lies the biological imperative to learn the art of preservation and steady grace.
The Cosmic Function of Mesha
Mesha is the sign of primordial emergence. In the grand cycle of the soul’s journey through the twelve rashis, Mesha represents the brave rupture of the cosmic womb. It is the moment the disembodied soul takes on a sharp, individual identity, accepting the challenge of embodiment, mortal limits, and physical resistance.
This is not an easy journey. Mesha carries the immense weight of being first. It cannot look backward for models or reassurance; it must forge the trail through unmapped territory. It represents the divine will to exist, to matter, to make an imprint upon the fabric of reality.
When Mesha rises in a chart or is activated by key transits, the soul is being summoned to take a stand. It demands that you cease asking for permission, stop hiding behind the safety of consensus, and step forward as an autonomous sovereign force. Mangala stands at the boundary, handing the soul the spear of courage and the shield of discipline.
Mesha teaches that existence is not a passive waiting room, but an arena of conscious engagement and purposeful action. The physical body is not an accident; it is the holy instrument through which Spirit tests its power against the friction of material reality. Courage is not the absence of fear, but the absolute refusal to allow fear to dictate the trajectory of the soul.
Conclusion
Mesha reminds us that without the spark of cardinal fire, the universe remains a cold, unformed expanse of potential. When kinetic drive is guided by noble purpose and tempered by the cool waters of self-restraint, the Ram breaks through the heaviest gates, clearing a path of renewal, sovereignty, and fearless vitality that inspires the world.
This is the eternal promise of Mesha: that no matter how deep the darkness of stagnation, a single spark of clear, unhesitating courage can ignite a revolution of light. The obstacle does not merely yield to the warrior; the obstacle becomes the stepping stone that elevates the soul into its authentic authority.
To walk the path of Mesha is to honor the gift of agency. It is to know that your will is a sacred fire, given not to burn down the temple, but to illuminate the path forward for those who have lost their way in the dark.
For those influenced by the thunderous call of Mesha, the charge is unmistakable. Master the fire within before you attempt to command the world without. Direct your sword against your own inner illusions of fear, resentment, and impatience. Let your life become an unyielding testament to the majesty of purposeful action, leading from the front with courage, honor, and sovereign grace.

Comments